Refurbishment Work at Height: Lessons From a Fatal Fall During Floor Repairs

Refurbishment work at height: when one team changes another team’s footing, HSE investigation findings

On a refurbishment project, one team can change another team’s working conditions without ever touching their work.

One team removes floorboards. Another is replacing joists. A place that was safe to stand can suddenly become an opening, an unsupported edge or an unstable surface.

That is what makes planning and coordination during refurbishment work so important.

An HSE report published on 2 October 2026 describes a fatal fall during floor repairs in Gloucestershire involving carpenter Richard “Felix” Roper. The case is a reminder that work at height risk assessments and methods cannot simply describe the site as it looks at the beginning of a job. They need to account for how the structure and working environment will change as the work progresses.

Key takeaways

  • Refurbishment work can change the safety of a working area very quickly.
  • Work involving floorboards, joists and structural supports needs careful sequencing.
  • One team’s activity can create a fall risk for another team.
  • Access controls and fall prevention measures should be in place before flooring or supports are removed.
  • Supervisors need to reassess the work when conditions change.
  • Where possible, the method should remove the need for people to work alongside an exposed opening altogether.

What happened?

On 30 August 2022, Richard “Felix” Roper was working on a refurbishment project in Gloucestershire.

He was replacing damaged joists while other workers were removing floorboards in the same area. As the work progressed, there were open gaps, missing joists and unsecured joists. The working environment was no longer the same as it had been before the floorboards and structural elements were removed.

The concrete below, however, was just as unforgiving.

HSE identified failures in the planning and supervision of the work, as well as the measures being used to prevent falls.

W G Carter Limited pleaded guilty to breaching Regulation 4(1) of the Work at Height Regulations 2005. At Bristol Magistrates’ Court on 24 September 2026, the company was fined £120,000 and ordered to pay £5,247 in costs.

Refurbishment floor with removed floorboards and exposed joists where a carpenter fell

Why does sequencing matter during refurbishment work?

Refurbishment presents a particular challenge because the workplace is constantly changing.

Removing a floorboard may be part of one worker’s task, but that action can change the protection available to someone working nearby. Removing a joist can affect the stability of a surface. Opening up part of a floor can create a new fall risk.

The question therefore cannot simply be: “Is this area safe now?”

Supervisors also need to ask: “What will become unsafe when the next stage of work begins?”

That should influence the sequence of work, access arrangements, fall prevention measures and the point at which work needs to stop for reassessment.

Lessons for site teams

Fall prevention checklist before flooring or supports are removed: plan the sequence, control access, put fall prevention in place, stop and reassess

1. Plan the sequence of work

Nobody should be expected to work on a surface that another team is dismantling around them. Before work begins, establish who is doing what, in what order and how each stage will affect the people working nearby.

The sequence should form part of the method, not be worked out informally as the job progresses.

2. Control access before creating the hazard

Do not wait until a floorboard has been removed or an opening has been created before deciding how people will be kept away from it. Access restrictions and suitable fall prevention measures should be established before removal begins.

Everyone affected by the work should understand:

  • ⚠️ who controls access
  • ⚠️ which areas are restricted
  • ⚠️ when those restrictions change
  • ⚠️ when work must stop for reassessment

3. Reassess when conditions change

A risk assessment carried out at the start of a refurbishment project cannot anticipate every physical change unless those changes are actively considered as part of the work.

Supervision should include checking whether the conditions assumed in the method still exist. If the floor, structure, access route or protection changes, the question should be whether the planned method is still safe.

4. Avoid the exposure where possible

Following the incident, the company changed its approach. Joists were installed from below using appropriate work-at-height equipment, and access to the first floor was prevented while the work took place.

That leads to an important question when planning similar work: can the task be completed without putting somebody next to the opening in the first place?

Where exposure to a fall can be avoided through a different method or sequence, that should be considered before relying on measures that protect someone once they are already working at height.

Questions supervisors should ask

Before flooring, joists or structural supports are removed, consider asking:

  • What changes when we start this stage of work?
  • Who else will be affected by those changes?
  • Are we removing something another worker is relying on?
  • Who controls access to the area?
  • What protection needs to be in place before removal starts?
  • At what point does the work need to stop and be reassessed?
  • Can the job be carried out from below or in another way that removes the exposure?

One particularly useful question for a site briefing is:

“What are we making unsafe, and what protection needs to be in place before we remove it?”

The wider lesson

The method used after the incident shows that another approach was possible. The work was subsequently carried out from below, using appropriate work-at-height equipment, with access to the floor above restricted.

The important lesson for other refurbishment projects is that the risk was foreseeable beforehand. When several trades are working in the same area, planning needs to consider not only each individual task but how those tasks interact.

A safe surface can stop being safe very quickly. Good planning, sequencing, supervision and fall prevention should make sure nobody discovers that after the floor beneath them has already changed.

Related reading: Stairwell opening safety: worker seriously injured in a preventable fall.

FAQs

Refurbishment constantly changes the structure. Removed floorboards, missing or unsecured joists, openings and unstable surfaces can appear as work progresses, and one trade’s activity can create a fall risk for another.

Yes. Work at height must be properly planned, appropriately supervised and carried out safely, and should be avoided where it is reasonably practicable to do the work another way.

Before the hazard is created. Access restrictions and suitable fall prevention should be established before floorboards, joists or supports are removed, not after an opening already exists.

A risk assessment written at the start cannot anticipate every change to the structure. Supervisors should check that the conditions the method assumed still exist and stop to reassess when the floor, structure, access route or protection changes.

Consider a different method or sequence, such as carrying out the work from below with suitable work-at-height equipment and restricting access to the floor above.

How Element Safety Can Help

Be Prepared

This incident was avoidable. The next one can be prevented.

Be Better

If your team carries out or plans refurbishment, floor repairs or work around openings, you already have this risk. The question is whether it is being controlled properly.

Element Safety provides practical, real-world training for teams who carry out, supervise or manage work at height.

That includes:

✅ Work at Height Training

✅ Work at Height for Managers

✅ Rescue from Height Training

✅ Practical fall prevention guidance

✅ Real-world risk assessment awareness

If your team works around floors, openings, platforms or structures that change as the job progresses, this is a risk worth taking seriously.

📩 training@elementsafety.co.uk 🌐 elementsafety.co.uk

Practical. Real-world. Emergency services instructor-led.

Contact Us

training@elementsafety.co.uk

 
01143 421 421